Most lingerie returns are not a sizing problem. They are a measuring problem — and specifically, the fact that almost nobody measures the one number that decides whether a one-piece garment will fit at all.
Our returns data points the same way. The pieces that come back are rarely the wrong size on paper. They are the right size in the bust and the wrong size in the torso, or the right size in the hip and half an inch short at the shoulder strap.
Torso first, hip second, bust third. That is the opposite of how most size charts are laid out, and it is why the charts keep failing people.
In this guide
01 / The basicsMeasure yourself properly, once
You need a soft tape measure and no clothes, or underwear you already trust. Three numbers, five minutes.
If you only have time for one, do the torso. If you do all three once and write them down, you will never need the tape again for that brand.
02 / The number nobody takesWhy torso length beats everything else
A teddy and a bodystocking are continuous garments. There is no waistband to adjust and no strap slack to take up. If the torso length is short by an inch, the fabric has nowhere to go — it pulls down at the shoulder and rides up at the hip at the same time, and no amount of adjusting fixes it.
This is also why one-size garments are so hit-and-miss across the industry. One size does not mean one fit. It means the fabric stretches across a range, and the range is narrower than the label suggests. A one-size bodystocking will fit a 30-inch torso well and a 34-inch torso badly, even though both wear the same dress size.
Our bodysuits and teddies run S through XL with individual grading, and the one-size pieces are cut to a stated torso range rather than a dress size. Check the range, not the letter. If you have not settled on which of the three shapes you want yet, the teddy vs bodysuit vs bodystocking comparison covers that decision first.
03 / The catalogueReading our size range honestly
What is actually in the range right now.
Swipe the table →
| Size format | Appears on | What it means |
|---|---|---|
| S / M / L / XL | 26 styles | Individually graded. XL is a separate pattern, not a stretched L. |
| One Size | 14 styles | Cut to a fixed torso range. Fits roughly a US 4–12 depending on the piece. |
| S/M and L/XL | 6 styles | Two-band sizing, typical for bralettes and mesh panties where the cup is unstructured. |
| One Size Queen | 4 styles | Same pattern scaled up — longer torso, wider hip. Roughly US 14–18. |
Fifty styles across four size systems. The letter on the label is the least useful part of the chart.
One detail that matters more than it looks: XL is graded on 15 of those 26 styles, not all of them. Each product page carries its own inch-based chart, and the numbers differ between styles because the fabric differs. Power mesh at 90% nylon and 10% spandex recovers differently from a flocked polyester at the same spandex content, so the same labelled size can sit a little differently across the range. That is normal, and it is why the chart lives on the product page rather than in one site-wide table.
04 / The one ruleBetween two sizes: size up in mesh, down in velvet
This is the rule that covers most of the range.
Mesh, fishnet, power mesh
These fabrics have 10–12% spandex and a lot of give, so the larger size still holds its line. The smaller size will dig at the strap and leave a mark by the end of the evening. A slightly loose mesh piece reads as draped; a slightly tight one reads as uncomfortable, and it is.
Flocked velvet & structured lace
Less recovery, more body. A loose velvet teddy sags at the seat in a way mesh never does. Velvet wants to be close — stay with your measured size, or go down if you are between.
Bralettes & unstructured cups
There are no wires to hold a shape, so a cup that is slightly too small rolls at the edge and shows under a thin top. Slightly loose sits flat.
Underwire & moulded cups
A moulded cup that is too large will gap at the top no matter how tight the band is. If the cup does not fit, the piece does not fit; take a different style.
The same rule applies across categories: bralettes should be sized up because there is no wire to hold a shape, while robes and loungewear forgive almost anything because the fit is soft.
05 / What causes returnsThe three mistakes that cause most returns
Underwear is the one category where the waistband, not the hip measurement, decides the size — a thong that sits at the hip is a different size from a brief that sits on the waist, and the two are not interchangeable. If you are ordering panties and thongs, check the band measurement before you commit.
06 / On the bodyHow to check the fit in thirty seconds
Once it is on, three tests, in this order.
If two of the three pass, keep it. If the sit test fails, return it and take the next size up in the same style, or switch to a piece with an adjustable back.
07 / AftercareMaking it last after it fits
Spandex does not wear out. It cooks. Heat is what destroys the recovery, which is why the care instructions matter more in this category than in almost any other.
Hand wash cold, press the water out inside a towel rather than wringing, dry flat. No tumble dryer, no radiator, no hanging a wet piece by its straps — the weight of the water will stretch them permanently and nothing brings them back. Store flat if you can, folded if you cannot, and keep rhinestone and chain pieces away from the machine entirely. A mesh laundry bag protects the drum, not the stones.
08 / GiftingIf you are buying for someone else
Ask for one number: her usual dress size, and whether she is tall or short through the torso. Short-torso and long-torso are more predictive than S versus M in this category.
Babydoll
It is the only shape cut loose from the bust down, so a size either way still hangs properly. See the babydoll and chemise collection.
Two-piece set
A top and a bottom can fail independently without ruining the whole look — lingerie sets.
Avoid one-piece teddies and bodystockings as gifts unless you know the torso length. They are the two shapes where guessing is most likely to be wrong, and they are also the two that are hardest to exchange discreetly.
For the rest of it — when to order, what each price band buys, and what to buy when you know neither the size nor the taste — see our lingerie gift guide.
09 / QuestionsFrequently asked questions
What if my measurements fall between two sizes?
Go up in mesh, fishnet and power mesh, and stay with your measured size in flocked velvet or structured lace. Mesh has 10–12% spandex and enough recovery that the larger piece still holds its line, while the smaller one will dig at the strap. Velvet behaves the opposite way — a loose velvet teddy sags at the seat, so it wants to sit close. For bralettes, go up; for underwire and moulded cups, do not size up to compensate, because a cup that is too large will gap no matter how tight the band is.
Why does one size fit differently across styles?
Because one size describes a stretch range, not a body. A one-size piece is cut to a fixed torso length and then relies on the fabric to cover the difference. Power mesh at 90% nylon and 10% spandex recovers differently from a flocked polyester at the same spandex content, so the same labelled size can sit a little differently across the range. That is why the chart lives on each product page rather than in one site-wide table — and why you should check the torso range rather than the dress size.
Should I measure with clothes on or off?
Over underwear you already trust, or nothing. Measuring over a bra adds the cup to your bust number, which is the one measurement where that error matters most. Keep the tape level and parallel to the floor, arms down, and do not pull it tight — if you can slide a finger under the tape, the tension is right. For torso length, measure as a loop from the shoulder point, down the front, through the crotch and back up to the same point, not as a straight line.
What if I am tall or short through the torso?
Torso length matters more than height, and the two do not always match — plenty of tall people have short torsos and the reverse. If yours is short, a teddy or bodystocking cut on a longer rise will pull at the shoulder and ride up at the hip the moment you sit, so favour pieces with an adjustable back or a shorter stated rise. If yours is long, avoid one-size bodystockings; take a graded S–XL style, where the torso is patterned separately rather than stretched to fit.
Measure the torso once. Check the range on the product page rather than the letter on the label. Size up in mesh, stay close in velvet.
That will get you a better result than any size chart alone.
10 / ShopStart where the fit is easiest
Written by the Free Tonight studio. Every product page carries its own inch-based chart.